Jump to content
Chinese-Forums
  • Sign Up

Should I Learn Mandarin or Cantonese


Recommended Posts

Posted

Personally I am more susceptible to Mandarin with Taiwanese accent (not the minnanese kind).

In the '60s and '70s, HK was under the onslaught of Taiwanese songs. Most people liked to hum the lyrics even though some couldn't understand the meaning.

By the way, actually it is not that hard for Beijingers to learn Cantonese.

Faye Wang and Leon Lai don't even speak fluent Cantonese but also sing popular Cantonese songs.

Posted
Faye Wang and Leon Lai don't even speak fluent Cantonese but also sing popular Cantonese songs.

I am afraid the above quote is not very true (their canto songs are popular).

Personally I find 兒化韻 quite pretentious, and prefer not to have it. And I don't think Putonghua requires that much of it (CCTV presenters don't seem to roll their tongues that much).

Posted

I think skylee means that Faye Wang speaks less than perfect Cantonese but can sing Cantopop.

I don't know if Leon is the most intelligent among the 4 kings or not. But undeniably he has the Chinese virtue of humility. He is very humble and seldom shows off.

But I would say Jackie Cheung or even Andy Lau sings better than Leon Lai while Aaron Kwok dances better than him.

But Leon Lai has a lot of fans especially those 30-50 yrs old married female. Some Japanese fans even organized teams from Japan to cheer during Leon's concert in HK. Some even tried to learn Cantonese because they wanted to understand Leon's songs.

Anyhow, I heard Leon was invited to be the singer in the opening ceremony in Olympics 2008 Beijing.

Posted

This is a very interesting turn of the discussion.

Sorry that I have not made it very clear. What I meant is both Faye Wong and Leon Lai speak fluent Cantonese and their Canto songs are popular. Faye Wong may have a trace of accent, but Leon Lai's Cantonese is perfect HK Cantonese (I doubt if his Putonghua is as good).

IMHO, Lai and Lau can act (you can't deny that Lau is a very good actor). Cheung sings like an angel. Kwok is good looking (but very sadly too short).

Posted

Born in Beijing, but moved to HK when he was four if I remember correctly. Wasn't Faye Wong born in Beijing too?

Roddy

Posted

Seems so. But as far as I know he came to HK when he was very young. He also spent some time in Britain, I think. Am not really that interested in him.

Posted
But Leon Lai has a lot of fans especially those 30-50 yrs old married female.

I think it's too early to use that sentence on Leon. 20-40 yrs old would be about right. He was still red hot 10 or so years ago. Going back 10 years, his fans were between 10-30, which looks reasonable to me.

Posted

I would guess mandarin caries you further. Off course in HK Cantonese is more useful.

Do not have to worry about the accent. Most people, even in Beijing, are not so sensitive about the accent.

Chinese belongs to all who use it as a way of communication

Posted
I would guess mandarin caries you further. Off course in HK Cantonese is more useful.

Do not have to worry about the accent. Most people' date=' even in Beijing, are not so sensitive about the accent.

Chinese belongs to all who use it as a way of communication[/quote']

mandarin opens some doors.

cantonese opens other doors.

don't be afraid to speak with your own accent.

just watch the tones and you'll be fine. :P

Posted
This is a very interesting turn of the discussion.

Sorry that I have not made it very clear. What I meant is both Faye Wong and Leon Lai speak fluent Cantonese and their Canto songs are popular. Faye Wong may have a trace of accent' date=' but Leon Lai's Cantonese is perfect HK Cantonese (I doubt if his Putonghua is as good).

IMHO, Lai and Lau can act (you can't deny that Lau is a very good actor). Cheung sings like an angel. Kwok is good looking (but very sadly too short).[/quote']

they're also good human beings, which is nice to see in people who are rich and famous... cheung's voice is so amazing. even as he gets older, he maintains the power and smoothness...

Posted

Leon Lai's mandarin is GOOD. It has no cantonese accent at all. He speaks in a Taiwan mandarin accent (it seems most of Southern China's mandarin speakers speak in this accent, including HK's good mandarin speakers). Funny how he has no Beijing accent. Faye Wong on the other hand, has a very thick Beijing or northern china accent.

Posted
Guest:

You are wrong. Leon Lai is more attractive to the 30-50 years old female group.

Just yesterday a 48-yr old Taiwanese lady who has assets more than NT$10 billion indicated in public that she wishes to be the girl friend of Leon. Read:

http://news.sina.com.hk/cgi-bin/news/show_news.cgi?ct=entertain&type=entertain&date=2004-02-10&id=160691

omg don't mention 許純美..she is the disgrace of taiwan and the whole of Taiwan is laughing at her. She has mental problems (seriously) but she thinks she's very popular because everyone is making a joke out of her. Phsychiatrists have said she has a certain mental disease (forgot which one) that makes her grasp on reality very weak. She is currently suing 吳宗憲 for 2 million NT$ (roughly 5.8million US$) for saying she has mental problems. The sad thing is, entertainment shows are asking her to go on their programs so they can grab higher tv ratings. Even the news follows her around because people think she's such a joke. Personally, I think she belongs in a mental institution.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted
i think we should talk about which accent sounds better, american or british. i'd say american accent is better Bcoz it is more popular in the world and it is quite similar to the Beijing Dialect..

cant agree more without seeing the sufficient evidence...

Posted

cantonese is only used in zhujiang delta, hk, and other OLD chinese communities abroad, and the trend is that mandarin will be more and more popular, due to the large and growing educated population in mainland china, and economic reasons that taiwan, singapore are also speaking mandarin.

and as i know, many mainlanders think that taiwan mandarin is too SOFT, called niangniang(women)qiang(accent).

Join the conversation

You can post now and select your username and password later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Click here to reply. Select text to quote.

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...